Photo: Vitaly Gariev / Unsplash
Two consumer surveys released in October told what looked like opposite stories. One, from LSEG Data and Ipsos, showed sentiment falling to its lowest level since 2011. A week later, the Conference Board reported that consumer confidence had bounced back to its highest level since June as gasoline prices eased. If you sell to everyday Americans, the temptation is to pick the survey that matches your mood. Do not. Read together, they say something more useful: shoppers are a little less frightened than they were, but they are still pinched, still worried about prices, and planning to be choosy. That is the customer walking into your store, or onto your website, as the holiday season begins.
What happened
As reported by CFO Dive and republished on Yahoo Finance, the Conference Board’s Consumer Confidence Index jumped 7.5 points in October to 91.7, beating expectations. The gain came from brighter expectations about the future and a better view of business and job conditions.
Gas prices were a big part of the story. AAA put the national average at $4.26 a gallon, down from $4.47 a month earlier but still 28% higher than a year ago. Consumers told the Conference Board they expect inflation to average 5.8% over the next 12 months. Consumer prices were up 3.7% in September from a year earlier, above forecasts.
The more sobering details were in the fine print. Consumers said they plan to cut back on spending for services and big-ticket durable goods over the next six months. When asked to write in what was on their minds, respondents pointed to prices, groceries, and oil and diesel costs. Samuel Tombs, chief U.S. economist at Pantheon Macroeconomics, put it simply: “The mood among consumers remains pretty bleak.”
Earlier in the month, TheStreet reported on the LSEG and Ipsos survey, which found its consumer sentiment index fell 5.3 points in October to 45.2. That was the lowest reading since October 2011 and the second-largest monthly drop on record, behind only April 2020. All four of its sub-measures declined, including views of current conditions, expectations and jobs. LSEG also projected that earnings growth for retail and restaurant companies would slow sharply in the third quarter.
Why it matters to small businesses
Big retailers can absorb a weak season. A small shop, restaurant, online store or service business often depends on November and December to carry the whole year. Here is how I read the signals.
- Relief is real but fragile. The October bounce tracked falling gas prices. If fuel costs rise again, confidence could slip just as quickly.
- Customers are prioritizing. Plans to trim spending on services and durable goods suggest people will still buy, but they will think harder about each purchase and favor what feels essential or meaningful.
- Price sensitivity is high. When people expect inflation near 6% over the next year, every price tag gets scrutinized. Value, clarity and trust matter more than usual.
The context: a long slide in the mood
Consumer mood has been sliding for most of the year. Sentiment has declined since February, when U.S. and Israeli strikes on Iran cut crude supply and pushed fuel costs higher. Inflation has been above the Federal Reserve’s 2% target for more than five years. The Conference Board’s own economist, Fergus McCormick, noted that despite the October rebound, confidence remains on the long-term downward trend of recent years.
At the same time, the broader economy is not collapsing. Employers added a surprising 165,000 jobs in October, and growth was strong over the summer. That combination, a working economy with frustrated consumers, is exactly why small businesses need to sell carefully rather than either panic or assume a boom.
A holiday playbook for small sellers
1. Lead with value, not just discounts
Deep discounts can train customers to wait and can wreck your margins. Instead, make the value obvious: bundles that solve a problem, gift sets at clear price points, free add-ons with purchase, or service guarantees. Tell people exactly what they get.
2. Build a clear good-better-best lineup
Pinched shoppers like choices. Offer an entry-level option that respects tight budgets, a middle option most people will choose, and a premium option for those who want to splurge. You will often sell more of the middle than you expect.
3. Sell meaning
Survey respondents are worried about groceries and gas. They are not going to buy a random gadget. They will buy something that feels personal, local or lasting. Tell the story behind your products, the people who make them, and why they will still matter in a year.
4. Protect your cash and inventory
- Avoid over-ordering. If something sells out, a waitlist can build demand without risking dead stock.
- Watch sell-through weekly and move slow items early with smart bundles rather than desperate markdowns in late December.
- Keep enough cash on hand for January, which is often slow for consumer businesses.
5. Make buying easy and low-risk
Clear return policies, gift receipts, local pickup and honest delivery dates remove the friction that makes careful shoppers hesitate. When people are anxious about money, reassurance converts.
6. Take care of your regulars
Your existing customers are your most reliable revenue in an uncertain season. Send them early access, a thank-you note or a small loyalty perk. It costs little and builds the kind of relationship that survives a tight budget.
7. Measure what matters
Track average order size, conversion rate and repeat purchases week by week. If order sizes are shrinking, adjust bundles and price points quickly instead of waiting for the season to end.
Questions to ask your team before Black Friday
- Which three products or services are we proudest of, and are they easy to find?
- What is our plan if a best seller sells out early?
- Which customers have not heard from us in six months, and what would bring them back?
- How fast can we answer a question by phone, email or message during the busiest week?
- What will we stop doing this season so we have time to serve customers well?
Simple questions, asked early, prevent the frantic decisions that cost small businesses margin in December.
What to watch next
- Gas prices. They drove the October rebound. Watch them closely through December.
- November confidence readings. Another improvement would suggest the bounce has legs. A reversal would argue for more caution in your ordering.
- Inflation reports. Higher-than-expected numbers could push the Federal Reserve to raise rates, which would make credit more expensive for you and your customers.
- Retail and restaurant earnings. Big chains’ results and guidance are an early signal of how shoppers are behaving in real time.
The bottom line
The customer this season is cautious, price-aware and a little more hopeful than a month ago. That is not a reason to fear the holidays. It is a reason to sell with more care. Offer clear value, tell the truth about your products, make buying easy, and treat your loyal customers like the gift they are. With Thanksgiving next week, there is no better moment to start. Gratitude, expressed sincerely to the people who keep your doors open, is still the most effective marketing a small business has.
Sources: CFO Dive, via Yahoo Finance; TheStreet, via AOL
Quick check
How much did you catch? Tap a question to see the answer.
1. What level did the Conference Board’s Consumer Confidence Index reach in October?
Answer: 91.7, up 7.5 points and the highest since June.
2. What inflation rate do consumers expect over the next 12 months, according to the Conference Board survey?
Answer: 5.8%.
3. The LSEG and Ipsos sentiment index fell to its lowest level since when?
Answer: October 2011.














