Founder Briefing: The Strand’s $1.5 Million PPP Repayment Is a Warning About Fine Print You Signed Years Ago

Rows of books on tall wooden shelves inside a bookstore

Photo: Joao Tzanno / Unsplash

Some of the most dangerous risks in a small business are not on your balance sheet. They are buried in forms you signed years ago, during a crisis, when you were moving as fast as you could to keep the lights on. Earlier this month, the U.S. Justice Department announced that the Strand, the famous New York bookstore, will repay nearly $1.5 million after the government said it improperly received a pandemic-era Paycheck Protection Program loan. The store says the mistake was unintentional. Whatever you think of the case, the lesson for every founder who took emergency money in 2020 and 2021 is the same: the certifications you signed still matter, and the rules can change between one application and the next.

What happened

According to The Associated Press, the Strand applied in 2021 for a second-draw PPP loan of $932,350. That second-round application required borrowers to certify that no member of Congress held a direct or indirect controlling interest in the business. The store’s owner, Nancy Bass Wyden, is married to U.S. Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon. The Justice Department said that made the store ineligible for the second loan.

Advertisement

The detail that should make every business owner sit up is this: the Strand’s first PPP loan, in 2020, did not require that certification at all. The rule appeared in the later program. Bass Wyden said the relief rules were changing rapidly, that the store did not realize the eligibility requirements had shifted between its first and second loans, that the funds were returned once the issue was raised, and that the store regretted the oversight. Sen. Wyden’s office said he and his wife do not discuss her business and that he had no involvement in the loan or the settlement.

U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro framed the government’s view sharply, saying the program “was created to save American jobs, not to enrich those who aren’t eligible.”

The AP report did not lay out the full settlement terms, how the roughly $1.5 million figure breaks down beyond the original loan amount, or whether the store admitted wrongdoing, so I will not guess at those details here.

Why it matters to founders

The Strand is not a typical small business. It was founded in 1927 by Bass Wyden’s grandfather, Benjamin Bass, and it is a landmark famous for advertising its 18 miles of books. But the mechanics of this case apply to any company that took government money in a hurry.

  • Eligibility can change between rounds. A program you qualified for once may have different rules the second time. Signing a familiar-looking form without rereading it is how good companies get into trouble.
  • Certifications are personal promises. When an owner signs that a business meets the requirements, the government treats that as a representation of fact. “We didn’t notice” is an explanation, not a defense you want to rely on.
  • Old money has a long tail. These loans were made five and six years ago. Enforcement and settlements are still arriving. If you received pandemic relief, do not assume the file is closed just because a loan was forgiven.

The context: a crisis built for speed

It is worth remembering how the pandemic programs worked. They were designed to get money out quickly, and the rules were revised repeatedly as lawmakers and agencies responded to a moving emergency. Borrowers were often filling out applications through banks that were themselves swamped. That speed saved many businesses. It also left a trail of certifications signed under pressure.

Advertisement

The Strand’s own pandemic story, as the AP recounted from earlier reporting, shows how desperate that period was. When lockdowns began in March 2020, the store furloughed 188 of its 217 employees. After receiving its first PPP loan, it brought back 30 workers in June 2020. In October of that year, Bass Wyden said revenue was down 70% and the business was unsustainable, and a public campaign to save the store drew more than 25,000 online orders in one weekend.

That is the reality many founders lived through: survival first, paperwork second. The problem is that the paperwork does not go away when the crisis does.

A practical compliance checklist for any government money you took

If your business received PPP loans, Economic Injury Disaster Loans, Employee Retention Credits, grants or any other public funding, here is how I would approach a self-review this winter.

1. Pull every application and certification

Gather the actual documents you signed, not just the approval emails. Note which program, which round, the date, and who signed. If your bank or a payroll provider submitted on your behalf, request copies.

2. Reread the eligibility rules for each round separately

Do not assume round two matched round one. The Strand case turned on a certification that existed in one round and not the other. Check ownership requirements, headcount limits, affiliation rules and any restrictions on who could have an interest in the business.

3. Map your ownership honestly

Who owned what at the time of each application, including spouses, family members, investors and related companies? Ownership and affiliation questions are where many otherwise honest businesses get tripped up.

4. Check how the money was used

Most relief programs restricted how funds could be spent. Match your spending records to the permitted uses for each program and keep that documentation organized.

5. If you find a problem, get professional help before you act

Bass Wyden said the store returned the money once the issue was raised. If your review turns up something questionable, do not try to fix it alone. Talk to an attorney and an accountant who handle government program compliance. How and when a problem is addressed can matter a great deal. This briefing is general education, not legal advice.

6. Build the habit going forward

  • Never sign a government or lender certification you have not read line by line, even if you signed a similar one before.
  • Keep a simple compliance file for every grant, loan and tax credit, with the rules as they stood on the day you applied.
  • Assign one person to own compliance, even in a five-person company.
  • Calendar the retention periods. Keep records for as long as the program, your lender and your advisers require.

What to watch next

  • More pandemic-era settlements. Cases like this suggest enforcement around relief programs is continuing years later.
  • New relief or incentive programs. With a new Congress taking shape after the midterms, founders may see new grants, credits or loan programs. Each will come with its own fine print.
  • Lender scrutiny. Banks that processed relief loans may ask more questions of borrowers, especially at renewal time.

The bottom line

I have enormous sympathy for anyone who was trying to save a business and its jobs in 2020 and 2021. That was a frightening time, and the programs helped a lot of people. But sympathy does not change the rule that matters most: when you sign, you own what you signed. Take an afternoon this month to pull your old files and read them with fresh eyes. If everything is clean, you will sleep better. If something is not, you will have found it on your terms, with time to get good advice. Either way, your future self will be grateful.

Source: The Associated Press, via Jefferson Public Radio

Quick check

How much did you catch? Tap a question to see the answer.

1. How much was the Strand’s 2021 second-draw PPP loan?

Answer: $932,350.

2. What certification did the second-draw application require that the 2020 loan did not?

Answer: That no member of Congress had a direct or indirect controlling interest in the business.

3. How many of its 217 employees did the Strand furlough when lockdowns began in March 2020?

Answer: 188.

ShareXFacebookLinkedInWhatsAppEmail

Latest stories

View all